This session is part of Reflective Meditation’s Daily Online Meditation practice at reflectivemeditation.org/dailyonline.
Continuing the whys, Linda looks at the conversation that follows meditation and reflection, and why it focuses on what actually happened in your meditation rather than on Dharma in general.
* * *
A rare kind of conversation
There are a lot of conversations we can have about Dharma and about meditation, and many of them don’t explicitly include what happened in your meditation. In fact, it’s rare to talk about what actually goes on. There’s even a common piece of advice in meditation communities not to talk about your meditation experiences. The reason I’ve mostly heard is that hearing about someone else’s meditation can set up comparisons, and there’s an emphasis on trying to keep Sangha members from comparing themselves to others.
I’ve certainly had the experience of hearing someone describe their meditation and thinking, “I want what she’s having.” So we don’t pretend comparison can’t happen in Reflective Meditation. It can. But we haven’t found it to be an obstacle to talking about experience more honestly and directly. In fact, we’ve found it can be very valuable to learn what other people experience during meditation, without turning it into a standard for our own. That feels like a skill that develops in our practice.
Part of what helps is knowing how similarly and how differently our body-minds work in meditation. Someone may describe a calm state that sounds wonderful, but over time you see that the state doesn’t last forever. Generally we’re not envious of difficult states, but it can be harder to hear someone talk about difficult experiences with ease and kindness if we’re still being harsh with ourselves. Even then, I think we can become more curious over time, if not right away, about the differences, instead of deciding that somebody is doing it better.
What the interview is
We’re trying to develop a particular kind of conversation after we meditate and reflect. Someone talks about what happened in their meditation, and another person listens with interest and kindness, with the Dharma as an anchor. We’re not trying to tell people what their meditation means, and we’re not trying to diagnose it or improve it.
I have to say this is not a normal conversation. Those of us who’ve been doing it a while feel it as more normal, but it’s not a normal conversation to come into. We’ve trained a lot of our people to do this and we’re still training others. It takes some learning to talk about your experience, to listen to another person’s experience, and to stay with it for a while. It becomes a practice in itself to interview others.
The place we start is that none of us holds the position of an idealized blank slate. We’re coming from what we know from our own meditative experience. And our training goes against a natural tendency in conversation, which is to right away share a similar experience, to help someone interpret or to do our own interpretation, or to reassure somebody that they’re doing a good job. We’re trying to restrain some of those impulses and practice something different: staying close to what the person’s experience is, just as we’ve learned to stay close to our own.
Questions without a right answer
We tend to ask questions in an interview, and sometimes make comments, but we ask questions without looking for a right answer. That’s interesting, isn’t it? We’re trying to gain a little more awareness of something that happened, and we’re learning as people share, because often we don’t really know. It’s one reason we intentionally train ourselves in the interview to do less rather than more.
We tend to ask in one or two areas of the meditation. We’re not trying to analyze the whole thing or take it apart to figure out what the meditation meant. We try to follow the interest of the meditator before our own, though sometimes our interest starts off the conversation, and that’s a way of modeling curiosity about your experience.
We often try to validate different ways of meditating, including experiences people disparage in themselves, like sleepiness, what they call distraction, or monkey mind. We’re interested in the labels we give our experience. We’re also looking at how calmness, settledness, and groundedness might happen idiosyncratically, even within meditating with a difficult experience. And we’re often looking for bits that are overlooked, parts of the experience someone glosses over, where we might ask a little more to bring out some awareness.
Collaborative, and not a map
Our intention is for the conversation to be collaborative. We’re sharing our views, and again, we’re not coming from a blank slate. We’re paying attention not just to the meditation you had but to you, the person we’re talking with. We’re not trying to push you to get anywhere, though on the back end, from my own experience, I’m feeling out ways to bring the conversation into Dharma. That’s an anchor for me. I’m not looking to create a situation where you’re asking whether you’re performing meditation right or wrong, and it’s very easy to feel that way even when that’s not the intention of the interviewer or of the person sharing.
We’re less interested in putting experience on a map, with some map of how experience should unfold. We’re interested in helping ourselves become familiar with the territory we’re inhabiting. What’s already happening, and how are you navigating your experience?
This connects back to our other whys. We don’t want to dilute your process of discovering your own resources, we don’t want to rush you into an interpretation, and we don’t want to tell you what your experience means. We want to stay close enough that you can know it in your own way and tell us how you see it.
The ordinary bits too
When we ask what happened in your meditation, we’re not asking because every meditation needs to produce something interesting. Not every meditation will. We’re asking because the ordinary bits are worth knowing too: the wanderings of the mind, the restless and boring parts, the repetitive stories. Knowing them makes us more intimate with our inner world. When we bring them out and talk about them, we have another opportunity to stay close to our experience rather than moving past it.
These conversations are an important part of our practice. We may connect more deeply with others by sharing what’s actually happening for us, and that may help us connect more deeply with ourselves. I’ve come to see there are different degrees of connection in these conversations, and not everyone has the same ease or confidence with them. Not every interview is special, and it doesn’t have to be. Over time, because they’re ongoing, they’ve become the glue of our Sangha. We don’t even know where people live or what they do, or if they’re retired, or how long they’ve been meditating, but we remember how people talk about their experience. We become aware of our own reactions and responses to what we hear, and we find Dharma teachings in these conversations. We can’t always see them right away, but the conversations help us see some things we couldn’t see on our own.
That’s a big part of what the Sangha is. It’s helping us see what we can’t see on our own.