Sati Sangha on Facebook

Why Do We Have Meditation Teachers at All?

This session is part of Reflective Meditation’s Daily Online Meditation practice at reflectivemeditation.org/dailyonline.

Linda takes up one of the bigger whys of Reflective Meditation: why have teachers at all, how do new teachers join the team, and what is a teacher’s role in a practice that puts your own experience first?

* * *

How a teacher joins the team

Welcome to anybody who’s newer to us this morning. We’re talking about some of the whys of Reflective Meditation. For those of you who join us regularly, you may notice that once in a while we add a new teacher to our team. You may not know how or why we do that, and you might not even wonder about it, but it’s one of the whys I’ll talk about this morning.

In Reflective Meditation we land somewhere in the middle way between the idea of a teacher as a Dharma expert and the idea that anyone who has practiced for a while can teach. In that range, we do think some things qualify someone to teach Reflective Meditation. We’re looking for more than simply being a long-time practitioner, but we’re not looking for someone who has reached some special attainment.

It’s more that there’s a body of Dharma we study and integrate into our teachers’ training, along with the ability to recognize the Dharma in your own experience. Both are important. It’s not all of the Dharma teachings, and it’s not always being able to recognize the Dharma in our experience, but it is a training to do so. So we want teachers who have spent enough time practicing Reflective Meditation to be familiar with the territory, who’ve experienced the ups and downs, the questions and uncertainties, and have learned some of the Dharma teachings deeply from their own practice.

Qualities that matter

We also have some qualities that aren’t really knowledge. Ethical integrity matters. Good interpersonal skills matter. So does the ability to listen to another person’s experience and sort through everything they’re saying about their meditation, and a willingness to recognize uncertainty. A teacher needs to resist the temptation to have an answer just because someone is asking a question.

There’s no special transmission in Reflective Meditation. That can seem quite radical compared to Buddhist traditions where transmission from teacher to student is an important part of becoming a teacher, signifying a recognized relationship to a lineage, to a particular person, and to a responsibility to carry the teachings forward. We’ve chosen a different model. We don’t see teaching as an authority passed down from person to person, and we’re not asking teachers to represent themselves as having attained something other practitioners haven’t.

Yet there are some very practical things we look at: two years of practice in Reflective Meditation, some retreat experience, an aspiration and intention to teach, good interpersonal and communication skills, and follow-through, commitment, and generosity toward the Sangha and the teachings. I put this information together on a website I created a few years ago, reflectivemeditationmentorship.org, so if you’re interested, take a look. These aren’t a checklist that makes someone a teacher. They’re more like the ground that gives us confidence that a person has enough experience to start taking on the responsibilities of teaching.

Teaching as a practice

Becoming a teacher isn’t something we consider finished once someone starts teaching. It becomes a practice. We have an ongoing mentorship process where teachers meet regularly to talk about their Dharma talks, about interviewing, about power dynamics, and about what it means to teach in an ongoing daily Sangha. We talk about what we’re seeing and learning from each other, and we’re willing to learn from each other, which is a nice benefit of having a team of teachers.

One thing the group has grappled with over the years is being called a teacher, a Dharma teacher. It rears its head every once in a while. Other names have come up: mentor, guide, coach, facilitator, and others I can’t remember right now. Because many of us come from traditions with one lead teacher, it’s been quite a process to reconcile ourselves with some of the Buddhist teachers on high, and to adjust our expectations for teaching without creating a hierarchy of spiritual attainments.

Yesterday we talked about how we currently have a team of teachers with two lead teachers, Nelly and me. I feel this gives more opportunity for teachers in training to find their own voice, their own style, and their own way of being more authentic to how they know the Dharma. That’s a high value in Reflective Meditation.

Room to learn

It also means there’s a learning curve. We value experimentation and innovation, and we want to learn from what doesn’t quite hit the mark. We’re not always operating on all cylinders, so we have another middle way for teachers, between being perfect and not good enough. We want some room to learn and grow without a tight container of compliance. We also really value the ability to reflect on and assess our intentions, our language, and our direction, and to hear feedback. That becomes essential in becoming a teacher.

I see teaching as a very valuable, continual practice of motoring the Sangha, staying engaged with what’s happening in the community and helping to keep it moving. We’re interested in developing teachers, and a newer idea is that we’re also interested in inviting long-term Reflective Meditation practitioners to share their experience. These aren’t necessarily the same thing. Some long-time practitioners have something valuable to offer without wanting to become a teacher, and we want to make room for that as well. Other ideas might emerge as we continue to practice and teach together.

We’re evolving over time, and there have already been unexpected shifts in how we teach and how we think about teaching. We want enough structure to take teaching seriously while leaving openness for something new to emerge. That feels consistent with our practice: we have some boundaries and intentions, and we also pay attention to what’s actually happening and let that inform what comes next.

What teachers are for

So we have teachers, and this isn’t the whole answer, but we have teachers not to have all the answers or to tell people how to practice. We have teachers to create conditions for meditators to discover their own way, while we continue discovering ours.

I’ll end the Dharma talk here, and we’ll meditate.